Open in Advisor
Home › Card Database › Gary Sheffield 95
Summer · Yankees
Gary Sheffield
The 44th best right fielder in MLB The Show 26, out of 248 that we rate. He also plays first base.
the worst right fielder in the gamethe best
36,975to buy it30,123sells back for6,852the difference8,000the game always paysIt is our own score for how good a card is. Rather than trust the number the game prints on the front, it reads the card's actual ratings — power, contact, fielding and the rest — and weighs them the way the game appears to. It runs past 100 because those underlying ratings do.
Where this card's 97.4 comes from · How the whole thing was built
Get the buy / sell / hold verdict Browse every card
Other Gary Sheffield cards
What the market is doingthe asking price, and what it is really selling for
The cheapest listing is 39,888, but the last 200 sales averaged 46,130 (over 2 days). Either somebody has listed under the going rate, or the price is falling faster than that average has caught up. 200 sales, over 2 days.
What he actually does
A balanced very good bat. Slow, and no help on the bases. Average in the field for a right fielder, with a solid arm.
Best at
- Durabilityvery good #164 97
- Plate visionvery good #178 95
- Powervery good #246 94
- Clutchelite #251 106
Worst at
- Fieldingaverage #1,408 60
- Reactionaverage #1,310 62
- Speedpoor #1,264 54
- Baserunningvery poor #1,112 22
Every ratingthe game's own numbers, where 125 is the ceiling
At the plate
On the bases
In the field
Small ball and health
Cheaper cards that do the same job
Jac Caglianone96 OVR · 2026 Home Run Derby
98.3
6,551
Jeromy Burnitz99 OVR · Moonshot
105.5
6,590
Lawrence Butler97 OVR · Topps Now
99.5
6,747
Bobby Abreu99 OVR · Moonshot
105.3
6,963
Walker Jenkins99 OVR · Pipeline
101.9
6,968
Same position, and we rate them within two points of this card.
Best Yankees cards
Babe Ruth99 OVR · Finest
115.9
—
Bernie Williams99 OVR · Milestone
109.8
268,150
Mickey Mantle99 OVR · Moonshot
109.2
earn
Giancarlo Stanton99 OVR · The Show Classics
108.5
earn
Chili Davis99 OVR · Milestone
108.4
269,997
Our rating reads the card's own ratings and weighs each one the way the game appears to. Nothing is hand-set. Across 1,564 hitters it lands within 0.93 of a point of the rating the game gives them.
It starts every hitter at 17.9 and adds the rest from here. How we know
Diamond Pulse is an independent fan tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by MLB, Sony Interactive Entertainment, San Diego Studio, or PlayStation. Card data reflects public MLB The Show sources and live marketplace listings.