Open in Advisor
Home › Card Database › Andy Pettitte 99
Awards · Yankees
Andy Pettitte
The 3rd best starting pitcher in MLB The Show 26, out of 677 that we rate.
the worst starting pitcher in the gamethe best
44,999to buy it32,000sells back for12,999the difference8,000the game always paysIt is our own score for how good a card is. Rather than trust the number the game prints on the front, it reads the card's actual ratings — power, contact, fielding and the rest — and weighs them the way the game appears to. It runs past 100 because those underlying ratings do.
Where this card's 108.8 comes from · How the whole thing was built
Get the buy / sell / hold verdict Browse every card
Other Andy Pettitte cards
What he actually does
A very good control, with very good break on the ball behind it. He misses bats at a very good rate, and he will not beat himself with walks. Enough stamina to start and go deep.
Best at
- Breakvery good #1 99
- Avoiding walkselite #1 125
- Controlvery good #1 99
- Avoiding home runsvery good #2 99
Worst at
Only one rating on this card sits in the weaker half of the game: Velocity at 83. Everything else is at or above the middle, which is most of why it rates where it does.
Every ratingthe game's own numbers, where 125 is the ceiling
Stuff
What hitters do against him
Holding up
Cheaper cards that do the same job
Jake Arrieta99 OVR · Finest
111.0
7,800
Andrew Alvarez99 OVR · Spotlight
107.8
8,900
CC Sabathia99 OVR · Milestone
107.5
15,993
Same position, and we rate them within two points of this card.
Best Yankees cards
Babe Ruth99 OVR · Finest
115.9
—
Bernie Williams99 OVR · Milestone
109.8
48,498
Gleyber Torres99 OVR · The Show Classics
109.2
earn
Mickey Mantle99 OVR · Moonshot
109.2
earn
Gerrit Cole99 OVR · 2026 Postseason
108.7
earn
Our rating reads the card's own ratings and weighs each one the way the game appears to. Nothing is hand-set. Across 1,376 pitchers it lands within 1.22 of a point of the rating the game gives them.
It starts every pitcher at 11.4 and adds the rest from here. How we know
Diamond Pulse is an independent fan tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by MLB, Sony Interactive Entertainment, San Diego Studio, or PlayStation. Card data reflects public MLB The Show sources and live marketplace listings.